| Design-Build
Hustles for Community College
By Tony Illia
Tattooed construction workers wearing
sleeveless shirts steadily toil in the hot, heavy air north
of the Gulf of Mexico as they lift and labor to build the
new 71-acre Bossier Parish Community College in northwestern
Louisiana. Situated east of Shreveport, across the Red River,
the groundbreaking 10-building, 348,055-sq-ft design-build
campus marks a unique approach to state college construction.
Bossier Parish Community College was a pilot program created
in 1966 to gauge the need for two-year commuter colleges throughout
the state. It opened in the fall of 1967 with 101 students
and eight instructors. During its first dozen years of operation,
the junior college provided transferable credits to a four-year
college or university. However, in the fall of 1979, the college
began granting two-year associate degrees and its enrollment
has skyrocketed since then.
The college today has over 4,250 students, 44 academic/training
programs and 300 employees squeezed into 139,000 sq ft of
facilities spread throughout the city. The college pays roughly
$1.4 million annually in rent and conditions lately have become
so crowded that the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools
told the college to upgrade its facilities or face possible
loss of accreditation. "Were maxed-out on space,"
says Tom Carleton, college chancellor. "Weve used
up every square inch available. Weve literally had to
clean out closets to place teachers and now weve been
forced to turn away new programs because theres no room
left for students."
In crisis mode, the state stepped in and lent a helping hand
on May 31, 2001, by creating a nonprofit corporation called
Campus Facilities Inc. (CFI). It charged the organization
with financing and building a new college campus lickety-split.
Subsequently, the Louisiana Local Government Environmental
Facilities and Community Development Authority jointly issued
$55 million worth of 25-year tax-exempt bonds to underwrite
the project. The state agreed to pay off the bond debt from
its general fund with a $4.1-million annual allocation.
For $500,000, the state acquired the schools future
site along U.S. Highway 80, just west of the Interstate-20/220
intersection in Bossier City. It now is leasing the property
back to Campus Facilities Inc. free of charge. However, title
to the buildings are being held by CFI until the bonds are
repaid in full. At that time, they will be transferred to
the colleges governing parent, the Louisiana Community
and Technical College System, at no cost.
Louisiana state-funded projects typically undergo a design-bid-build
process overseen by the office of Facility Planning and Control.
All publicly funded jobs must first be introduced in the governors
budget then receive legislative approval, a process which
lends itself to politicking. This traditional procurement
method often can be slow and tedious, taking up to seven times
longer than a design-build delivery approach. "Normally,
capital construction projects are very lengthy and political,"
says J. Kevin McCotter, CFIs president. "With this
[design-build] process, we put together alternative financing
while forming a cooperative endeavor agreement with the state.
It has allowed us to build an entire community college campus
in just 33 months."
Under the states capital outlay process, a college
campus of this size would take 20 years to finish. But as
a nonprofit corporation, CFI had the flexibility to issue
request-for-qualifications for design-build teams, which it
did on Aug. 23, 2001. Submissions were judged on the teams
experience, technical abilities, construction capability and
organization, among other criteria. On Sept. 28, 2001, Shreve
Land Construction, a division of Brice Building Co. Inc.,
Birmingham, Ala., along with Slack-Alost-McSwain & Associates
Architects, Shreveport, landed the $51.3-million cost-plus
contract, which has a fee component for architectural services.
"The nonprofit allowed us to establish the ground rules
by which the project would be administered," says McCotter.
"Based on our knowledge of design-build, we felt that
it offered the type of speed and efficiency that could best
meet our needs."
CFI was able to circumvent the states normal practice
of funding design before construction can begin. In this instance,
bidding on the foundation and structural steel packages started
as the final drawings were being finished. The accelerated
schedule also moved up the completion date, saving money the
college spent on rent payments.
This project marks the first time that an entire college
campus has been built from the ground up in Louisiana. It
also is the largest state-backed job since the Louisiana State
Universitys Medical Center at Shreveport opened in 1969.
"The original campus masterplan called for a series of
smaller buildings," says Carl M. Bantle, CEO of Shreve
Land Construction. "One of the first things we looked
at was minimizing the number of structures needed."
Simple Plan
CFIs original plans specified several distinctive-looking
one-and two-level buildings. But to capture more space and
eliminate the need for construction of an additional structure,
the design-build team went with some three-story buildings.
Shreve Land and Slack-Alost-McSwain also chose structurally
similar buildings for time and cost savings, but varied the
site orientation and facades to give them a different appearance.
 |
 |
| Hands-on team keeps
project on fast-tracked schedule. |
The two-phase project, which broke ground on Sept. 2002,
consists of 10 steel-framed structures with block walls and
a combination of exterior finishes ranging from precast concrete
and brick to EIFS and stucco. The new campus will have a two-story,
49,550-sq-ft library/administration building; a three-story,
49,550-sq-ft health/natural sciences building; an 18,165-sq-ft
single-level, double-height auditorium; and a three-story,
48,600-sq-ft business/computer-science/liberal arts building.
There also is a three-story, 48,600-sq-ft community education/workforce
development building; a three-story, 48,600-sq-ft behavioral
and social sciences/math building; a two-story, 45,845-sq-ft
student activities building; and a single-level, 40,085-sq-ft
athletics/physical education building. The campus also has
a maintenance building and a central service plant.
The buildings are clustered in a horseshoe configuration
with a ring road encircling the campus. The three-story buildings
visually anchor each corner of the college and are separated
by lower-level structures. Between buildings, there is a network
of steel canopied walkways that provide pedestrian shade,
plus a landscaped student area at the campus center. "Almost
half of the campus square footage is in traditional
classrooms, with the other half in unique spaces," says
Michael A. Alost, vice president of Slack-Alost-McSwain. "But
the classrooms are flexible and can be converted."
The four classroom buildings have a load-bearing exterior
frame with minimal columns and sheer walls, enabling the interiors
to be adapted for different uses if needed. There also is
a building pad at the end of the horseshoe opening that provides
up to 60,000 sq ft for future growth.
Blocked Out
Speed wasnt the only challenge. The site is located
under the flight path of nearby Barksdale Air Force Base,
home of B-52 bombers. The 185,000-lb planes measure 185 ft
wide and 159.4 ft long and have eight jet engines. Having
such massive aircraft roaring overhead meant adding engineering
to create a quiet campus learning environment. "Stopping
low frequency noise with architecture is very difficult, says
Alost. "So we tried to make all of our design choices
serve more than one function."
The design-build team selected heavy block exteriors, which
makes construction quick and cost-effective while helping
to dampen sound. In addition, double-insulated windows were
used to deal with harmonic vibration and the buildings have
pitched metal roofs that refract noise. Extra layers of drywall
were added underneath to serve as sound buffers. Selecting
block and metal materials also meant minimal maintenance for
the college. The campus design keeps everything clean and
functional with no exterior painting or exposed wood.
But the site once was a river bottom and now consists of
sand and mud, which presented other challenges. Covered with
2,000 locust trees and thorn bushes, the site looked like
an "old cow pasture," Alost says. After grubbing
and clearing, roughly 200,000 cu yd of soil was imported to
raise the campus elevation for proper drainage. And to reinforce
the riverbed subsurface, the design-build team used wood friction
piles, similar to telephone poles. The buildings sit atop
roughly 2,300 such piles, measuring 14 in. in diameter and
40 ft long. The woodpile alternative proved cost-effective
versus steel and concrete. Despite concerns about potential
rotting, the specially treated wood piles are in an airtight
environment that prevents decay after they are driven into
the ground.
 |
 |
| Three-story buildings
anchor campus corners. |
While bad weather is a normal part of any construction project,
it can take on a special meaning in Louisiana. The winter
months also bring hurricane season. Although Bossier City
is too far north to feel any real impact from storms rolling
off the Gulf of Mexico, it still experiences residual effects.
As a result, heavy rain supersaturated the project site last
December and this February creating ankle-deep mud. Shreve
Land was forced to temporarily stop work and scrape and pile
mud in mounds 6 ft high so that the site could properly dry
before redistributing the soil. Site conditions and bad weather
aside, the project, which will employ 300 workers at the height
of activity, has gone smoothly. The majority of the new college
should open by December, followed by the gymnasium and theater
in February 2005.
The project completion will come just in the nick-of-time.
Next year, the state of Louisiana is implementing stiffened
university admissions standards, requiring minimum grade point
averages as opposed to its previous open-door policy. The
toughened entrance requirements are expected to push more
students into the states community colleges, which are
now bracing for an enrollment boom. By conservative estimates,
Bossier Parish Community College expects to see a 20% increase
in enrollment during its first full year as a new campus.
However, the new facility will have capacity for 8,000 full-time
students, enabling the college to double its current enrollment
and add new programs.
"The design-build concept has worked exceptionally well.
We are building a complete campus from start to finish in
less than three years, which is unheard of in the state of
Louisiana," says Thomas C. Williams, vice chancellor
for finance and administration. "Basically, we have been
here for 35 years, but this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity
to build a college campus from scratch."
The author is a Las Vegas-based correspondent
for The McGraw-Hill Cos. He regularly reports on design and
construction industry issues.
All photos courtesy of Shreve Land Construction
Click
here for features archives >>
|